Pantone and colour accuracy: getting your logo colour right
The logo looks exactly right on screen, yet on the mug the blue turns purple, on the T-shirt it looks dull and on the pen noticeably darker. That is not necessarily the printer's fault: colour depends on the colour system, the material, the printing method and even the light you view it in. This guide explains how Pantone, CMYK and RGB relate to each other and what you can do yourself so that your branded merchandise carries your brand colour as accurately as possible.
It is written for marketing managers and designers who order branded products in different materials and need to decide which colour code to supply, what deviation to accept and when to ask for a physical sample.
In short
- Supply the colour as a Pantone code, not just HEX. A screen colour (RGB) tells the printer nothing about which ink to mix.
- The same Pantone number looks different on different surfaces. Pantone itself stresses that the same colour looks quite different on coated (C) and uncoated (U) paper.
- The printing method determines accuracy. Screen and pad printing inks can be mixed to Pantone; digital methods and embroidery give the closest match.
- Accuracy is measurable. Colour difference is expressed in ΔE; according to X-Rite, a typical customer tolerance in graphic arts is 2–6 ΔE.
- For a critical colour, ask for a physical sample. A digital mock-up checks placement, not colour.
- Your brand book must state the colour in several systems. Pantone C and U, CMYK, RGB/HEX and, where needed, textile and thread equivalents.
Why the logo colour changes on a product
There are three causes, and they often occur together.
1. Screen and print use different colour models
A screen creates colour with light (RGB), print with pigment. On screen you see emitted light; on a product you see reflected light. Vivid blues, greens and oranges that glow on screen may not be achievable at all in four-colour (CMYK) printing. That is why the Pantone Color Bridge guide shows each Pantone colour next to its closest CMYK simulation – and the word "closest" matters.
2. The material changes the colour
Pantone explains that on coated paper the ink sits on the surface and absorbs little, while uncoated paper absorbs as much as possible – which is why the same Pantone colour looks quite different on coated and uncoated paper. The same logic applies to promotional products: glossy plastic and enamelled metal behave like coated paper; cotton, wood, cork and paper like an uncoated surface. The base colour matters too: white ink on a white mug and white ink on a black bag are two different jobs.
3. Light fools the eye
X-Rite's glossary defines metamerism as the phenomenon where two colours appear to match under one light source but not under another. Office LED lighting, daylight and trade-fair spotlights can all change how the same product looks. The standard illuminant for graphic arts is D50, and X-Rite recommends evaluating colour in a light booth or at least in controlled daylight.
Pantone, CMYK, RGB and HEX: what to use when
| System | What it is | Where it is used | For branded merchandise |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pantone C / U (PMS) | Standardised spot colours with a defined ink recipe | Screen printing, pad printing, packaging | Main reference; always give it with the C or U suffix |
| Pantone TCX / TPG | Colour system for textiles and home goods | Fabric dyeing, apparel, textiles | Useful when the product itself (e.g. a shirt or bag) must be dyed in the brand colour |
| CMYK | Four-colour printing with cyan, magenta, yellow and black | Digital, UV and DTF printing, print media | Simulates the Pantone colour; accuracy depends on the shade |
| RGB / HEX | Screen colours | Web, presentations, digital mock-ups | Not a print reference; use on screen only |
| Thread card | An embroidery thread maker's colour range | Embroidery | The thread closest to the Pantone is chosen; ask for a sample |
The current Pantone Formula Guide contains 2,614 spot colours of the Graphics System on coated and uncoated stock, while the textile guide (Fashion, Home + Interiors) has 2,625 colours whose paper version TPG matches the cotton standard TCX. They are separate systems: a graphics Pantone code is not automatically the same as a textile code.
Colour guides age
Pantone recommends replacing its graphics guides every 12–18 months, because pigments break down with handling and light and the paper yellows. If your designer compares a sample with a ten-year-old fan deck, the "wrong colour" may be in the fan deck.
Branded merchandise: how accurate can each method be?
The same logo cannot always be identical across products, but choosing the right method keeps the difference to a minimum. The table shows the general logic; the options for a specific product are confirmed in the quote.
| Method | Colour basis | Pantone match | Keep in mind |
|---|---|---|---|
| Screen printing | Mixed spot ink | Good, ink is mixed to the code | Dark textiles need an underbase; each colour is a separate layer |
| Pad printing | Mixed spot ink | Good on small areas | Thin ink layer; the base colour may show through |
| UV printing | CMYK, often with white | Simulation | Suits multicolour logos; vivid spot shades may look duller |
| DTF printing | CMYK with white | Simulation | Suits small runs and full colour on textiles |
| Embroidery | Ready-made threads | Closest thread colour | Glossy thread reflects light, so the shade shifts with the viewing angle |
| Laser engraving | The material's own tone | Not applicable | No ink; the result depends on the metal, wood or coating |
Special cases: white, metallic and neon
A white logo on a dark product needs opaque ink or an underbase; otherwise the base shows through and the white turns greyish. Metallic and neon shades cannot be reproduced in four-colour printing, because CMYK inks contain neither metallic particles nor fluorescent pigments. If your brand uses gold, silver or neon green, ask whether the chosen method offers a special ink, or agree on a substitute colour in your brand book for when a special ink is not possible.
If the brand colour is critical, choose a spot-colour method where possible. If the product needs a full-colour image, accept that the brand shade is a simulation and confirm it with a sample.
Colour tolerance: how accurate is "accurate"?
Colour difference is measured with a spectrophotometer and expressed in ΔE (delta E). The smaller the number, the closer the colours. According to Variable Inc., most people cannot perceive a difference below 1.0 ΔE. According to X-Rite's colour guide, a typical customer tolerance in graphic arts lies between 2 and 6 ΔE, and tolerances below about 2 ΔE are generally unachievable given normal process variation.
What this means for the buyer:
- Agree on the tolerance before production, especially for large volumes and your main brand colour.
- Define the reference: a Pantone fan deck, the previous batch or an approved sample.
- Define viewing conditions: assess the sample in daylight or a light booth, not under a yellow office lamp.
- Allow for the material: wood, cork and natural textiles inevitably have a wider tolerance than white plastic.
Mock-up, sample and pre-production sample
You always approve a mock-up before production. It is important to understand what each step checks.
Digital mock-up
The mock-up shows the logo position, size, number of colours and Pantone codes. It is necessary, but the colour on screen is not the print colour. On the mock-up, check that the correct code and C/U suffix are stated – not whether the shade looks right on your monitor.
Physical sample
If the colour is critical, ask for a physical or pre-production sample in the same material and with the same method. Its price and timing are agreed in the quote. When approving it, check the colour, contrast against the base, legibility of fine details and durability.
The role of the brand book
A good brand book saves time on every order because the supplier does not have to guess the colour. For ordering branded merchandise it should include:
- the main colours as Pantone C and Pantone U codes;
- CMYK values, and RGB/HEX for screens only;
- a textile code (TCX) for dyed products, if needed;
- one-colour, reversed and monochrome versions of the logo, since many methods print in one colour;
- the minimum logo size and clear space;
- guidance for when the material cannot carry the brand colour – for example a white or black logo on a coloured product.
If you do not yet have a brand book or it ignores product materials, our advertising design service can help. More practical guides are on our blog.
Example: one blue logo on four products
Example: the scenario below is fictional; the numbers and shades are illustrative and are not Logotrade data.
- Starting point: the company's main colour is a deep blue Pantone shade. For a trade fair it needs T-shirts, ceramic mugs, plastic pens and cotton bags.
- Information for the supplier: the designer sends a vector logo, the Pantone C and U codes and CMYK values.
- Choice of methods: screen printing for shirts and bags, pad printing for pens – all with mixed spot ink. Because of extra multicolour graphics, the mugs get UV printing, where the blue is a simulation.
- Material effect: on the cotton bag the blue looks duller than on the white plastic pen. The client accepts this, knowing how uncoated surfaces behave.
- Sample: a physical sample is ordered for the mug, because the simulation carries the highest risk.
- Check: samples are compared in daylight against a fresh Pantone fan deck. The mug blue is adjusted before production.
Checklist before ordering
- The logo is a vector file (AI, EPS, PDF or SVG).
- Colours are given as Pantone codes with the C or U suffix.
- CMYK values are included for digital methods.
- Textile or thread equivalents are defined for textiles, where needed.
- You know which method suits each product and whether it uses spot or CMYK colour.
- The product's base colour and material have been considered.
- A one-colour or reversed logo is available.
- It is agreed what the sample is compared against and under which light.
- For a critical colour, a physical sample is included in the quote.
- For a repeat order, the previous approved batch is referenced.
Common mistakes
- Only a HEX code. From a screen colour, the printer has to guess the shade.
- No C/U suffix. "Pantone 286" without a suffix leaves the expected appearance open.
- Judging colour on screen. The shade of a mock-up on a monitor depends on the display settings.
- Expecting an identical shade on every product. Cotton, plastic and ceramics do not behave the same.
- An outdated fan deck. A faded colour guide gives a false reference.
- Skipping the sample for a critical colour. Correcting after production costs many times more.
Frequently asked questions
Is a HEX code enough to print a logo?
No. HEX and RGB are screen colours. For print, supply the Pantone code, plus CMYK values for digital methods.
What is the difference between Pantone C and U?
C stands for coated paper, where ink sits on the surface; U for uncoated paper, which absorbs ink. The same number looks different on these surfaces.
Why is the embroidered logo a different shade?
Embroidery uses ready-made threads, and the one closest to the Pantone is chosen. Glossy thread reflects light, so the shade changes with the viewing angle.
How much colour difference is normal?
According to X-Rite, a typical customer tolerance in graphic arts is 2–6 ΔE. Agree on the tolerance and reference before production.
Do I need a physical sample for every order?
Not always. For a simple one-colour logo on a familiar material, a mock-up is often enough. If the colour is critical for the brand or the method uses CMYK simulation, it is worth asking for a sample.
Why is the colour of a repeat order slightly different?
Batches can differ in ink, material and conditions. Reference the previous approved batch when reordering and keep one sample.
Since 2004, Logotrade OÜ in Tallinn has helped companies choose and brand products so that the logo looks the way it does in the brand book. We are a member of the international promotional products networks PSI and ASI and of the Estonian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, and we deliver across Estonia. See our branding services, product range and previous work.
Send your vector logo, Pantone codes and the products you have in mind to logo@logo.ee or use the contact form – we will recommend the right method and confirm the mock-up, sample, price and timeline in the quote.