Gift card or physical gift: which works better for a company?
A gift card feels like the safe choice: everyone buys what they like and nothing ends up unused in a drawer. A physical gift, on the other hand, is remembered, carries your brand and shows that someone actually thought about the recipient. This guide compares both options on the criteria that really matter in a company – tax, total cost, memorability, visibility and logistics – and shows when it makes sense to combine them.
If you are planning employee gifts for Christmas, a company anniversary or as a thank-you for a job well done, this article will help you decide based on numbers and research rather than gut feeling.
In short
- In Estonia, a gift card and a physical gift given to an employee are treated the same for tax purposes: both are fringe benefits taxed with income tax at 22/78 and social tax at 33%.
- The 21-euro tax-free limit for promotional gifts applies only to non-employees and assumes a branded promotional item – for gift cards it should be checked separately.
- Research shows recipients value flexibility more than givers expect, but a cash-like gift creates no link to your brand.
- A physical gift wins on visibility and memorability; a gift card suits a diverse, distributed team better.
- Often the best solution is a combination: a small, high-quality branded item plus an element of choice.
Tax in Estonia: for employees, both are fringe benefits
A common misconception is that a gift card is "simpler" or "more tax-free" than an item. According to the Estonian Tax and Customs Board, gifts, reception and entertainment costs for employees are taxed as fringe benefits under § 48 of the Income Tax Act and declared on annex 4 of form TSD (EMTA: gifts, donations and reception costs). In the example on the same page, a company receives a spa gift card with an office supplies order and gives it to a hard-working employee as a bonus – this is a fringe benefit valued at the market price of the benefit.
On fringe benefits the employer pays income tax at 22/78 and social tax at 33%, with social tax calculated on both the value of the benefit and the income tax on it (EMTA guide on fringe benefits). In other words, the tax burden is the same whether the gift is a gift card, a thermos or a gift box.
The calculation
Example: the market price of the gift is 40 euros per employee.
- Income tax: 40 × 22/78 = 11.28 euros.
- Social tax: (40 + 11.28) × 33% = 16.92 euros.
- Total cost to the company: 40 + 11.28 + 16.92 = 68.20 euros.
So every euro given to an employee costs the company about 1.70 euros. Budget for this regardless of the form of the gift.
Where the difference does appear
- Clients and partners. In Estonia, a branded promotional gift to a non-employee is income-tax-free up to 21 euros excluding VAT, and no VAT is charged on gifts up to 10 euros excluding VAT. A gift card, however, usually carries neither your logo nor an advertising message, so check with your accountant whether the promotional gift exemption can apply to it at all. Above 21 euros, the full cost is taxed at 22/78.
- Health promotion. In Estonia, health promotion expenses up to 400 euros per employee per year are not taxed as a fringe benefit if the employer offers them to all employees (EMTA: health and sport). This is a separate allowance, not a gift rule – whether a particular sports or spa card qualifies should be checked before buying.
- VAT. The EU divides vouchers into single-purpose and multi-purpose ones. For a single-purpose voucher, the place of supply and the VAT due are known when it is issued; for a multi-purpose voucher, VAT arises only when the goods or services are actually handed over (Directive (EU) 2016/1065). How this is reflected in your accounts depends on the card type.
What research says: flexibility versus memorability
Economists have measured the "efficiency" of gifts for more than thirty years. In Joel Waldfogel's 1993 study, Yale students valued 246 non-cash gifts at an average of 83.9% of what the giver paid. Later studies with broader samples found the opposite: one reported a median value of 111%, and a real-stakes auction experiment 135% (American Economic Association). A well-chosen item can therefore be worth more to the recipient than it cost – a poorly chosen one, considerably less.
In experiments by Francesca Gino and Francis Flynn, recipients appreciated gifts chosen from their wish list more than surprises the giver came up with, and money even more, although givers predicted the opposite (Stanford GSB). A 2023 West Virginia University study found that givers avoid digital gift cards more than recipients actually mind them – for recipients, a digital card is easy to use and hard to lose (WVU).
From the company's point of view, the other side matters just as much. A gift card gets spent and forgotten; a branded item stays in everyday use. According to ASI's international study, on average 82% of promotional product recipients could recall the advertiser, and items are kept for about six months on average (ASI). With employee gifts the goal is not sales but a sense of belonging – and that comes more from a shared, recognisable item than from a balance in an online shop account.
Comparison table: gift card, physical gift and combination
| Criterion | Gift card | Physical branded gift | Combination |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tax when given to an employee (Estonia) | Fringe benefit | Fringe benefit | Fringe benefit on both parts |
| Recipient's freedom of choice | High | Low unless a choice is offered | Medium to high |
| Brand visibility | None or minimal | High and long-lasting | High |
| Memorability and emotion | Low, tends to blend into everyday spending | High if the item is good quality | High |
| Logistics | Simple, fast | Requires selection, design and production time | Requires planning |
| Distributed team, several countries | Works well if the card is valid in the recipient's country | Requires delivery logistics | Item shipped, card sent digitally |
| Risks | Unused balance, expiry, limited store network | Wrong size or taste | Higher budget if both parts are large |
Employee gifts: when to choose a gift card and when an item
A gift card works when
- the team is very diverse (age, lifestyle, country) and a shared item that suits everyone is hard to find;
- the purpose is financial recognition, such as a bonus or a milestone, rather than team spirit;
- time is short and there is not enough left to produce a physical product;
- the card is linked to an experience your people value (e.g. culture, sport) and its terms are clear.
A physical gift works when
- you want to strengthen team spirit and the brand – for example a shared warm jacket, a quality thermos or a company anniversary gift;
- the gift has symbolic meaning (anniversary, end of a project, welcoming a new employee);
- you want the gift to be visible in the office, at events and at client meetings;
- you can offer a couple of options to reduce the "wrong item" risk.
A good starting point for choosing an item is our promotional products catalogue, where you will find drinkware, corporate clothing and textiles and electronics. If the gift needs to make an impression, take a look at our premium corporate gifts.
The combined solution: a small item plus choice
Many companies solve the dilemma by letting the physical part carry the brand and the emotion, while an element of choice adds flexibility. Models that work:
- Gift box + card. A small, well-packed branded gift set with a gift card or code inside.
- Choice gift. The employee picks one of 3–4 pre-selected branded products. The brand stays, but the "one size fits all" problem disappears.
- Personalised item. Laser engraving with a name or greeting turns an ordinary item into a personal one without significantly increasing the budget.
- Local added value. An item made in Estonia together with a gift card for a local service also supports local business.
Remember that tax is calculated on the full market price of the gift, so a combination is not cheaper in tax terms – it is simply a better experience for the same money. More ideas can be found in our blog.
Example: a Christmas gift for a 60-person company
Example: a Tallinn IT company has 60 employees, 15 of whom work in Finland and Latvia. The approved budget, as total cost including taxes, is 4,100 euros. The HR manager is weighing a 40-euro gift card against a branded gift.
- Taxes are calculated in advance. A 40-euro gift costs about 68.20 euros with taxes, roughly 4,092 euros for 60 people – within budget regardless of the form of the gift.
- The team is asked. A short anonymous survey shows that most prefer something practical, but a third want the freedom to choose.
- A combination is chosen. Everyone receives a branded thermos (with an embroidered winter hat as an alternative) and a small gift card. For colleagues abroad, a card valid in their country is chosen.
- The request for quote is sent in October. It includes quantities, logo files, delivery addresses and the deadline. Production time and price are confirmed in the quote.
- Result. Employees get both a personal choice and an item they will use for years. Accounting declares the full value of the gift on TSD annex 4.
Checklist before deciding
- Are the recipients employees or clients? The tax treatment depends on it.
- Does the budget include fringe benefit taxes (about +70% of the gift value in Estonia)?
- What is the purpose of the gift: recognition, team spirit or brand visibility?
- Is the team spread across several countries, and is the gift card valid there?
- Are the gift card's validity, places of use and rules for any remaining balance clear?
- For a physical gift, have you asked for production time, minimum quantity and price in the quote?
- Can you offer a choice (sizes, colours, an alternative product)?
- Does the gift come with a personal greeting from management?
Common mistakes
- Assuming a gift card is tax-free. For an employee it is a fringe benefit like any other gift.
- Applying the 21-euro rule to employees. That limit applies only to promotional gifts given to non-employees.
- Choosing a cheap item "so the logo is on it". A poor-quality product damages your reputation more than a gift card. Fewer, but better.
- A gift card without a personal message. A code in an email feels like a transaction, not a thank-you.
- Forgetting validity and store network. A card that is valid only in one city or expires in three months does not suit everyone.
- Ordering at the last minute. Producing a branded item takes time – ask for the schedule in your very first request.
Frequently asked questions
Is a gift card for an employee tax-free in Estonia?
No. According to the Estonian Tax and Customs Board, a gift to an employee, including a gift card, is a fringe benefit subject to income tax at 22/78 and social tax at 33%.
Is a branded gift for an employee cheaper than a gift card?
Not in tax terms – both are fringe benefits. The difference is in value: a branded item creates a link to your brand and stays in use, while a gift card offers freedom.
Can a client receive a gift card tax-free within the 21-euro limit?
In Estonia, the tax-free limit applies to branded promotional gifts. Since a gift card usually carries no advertising message, discuss its treatment with your accountant. A branded item up to 21 euros excluding VAT is the safer choice.
What is the right gift value per employee?
There is no fixed norm. Bear in mind that in Estonia each euro of the gift costs about 1.70 euros with taxes, and set the budget by total cost rather than by gift price.
Can a gift card supporting sport or health be tax-free?
In Estonia, health promotion costs are tax-free up to 400 euros per employee per year if the benefit is offered to all employees. Check with the EMTA guide or your accountant whether a specific card qualifies.
How can a physical gift be made personal?
Offer a choice, add an engraved name or a hand-signed card, and choose a product that fits your team's lifestyle. You will find inspiration in our portfolio of completed projects.
Logotrade's experience
Logotrade OÜ has operated in Tallinn since 2004, helping companies get from the first idea to the finished gift. We are a member of the international promotional products networks PSI and ASI and of the Estonian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, and we deliver orders across Estonia. Our services include logo application and design.
Describe the recipients, budget and deadline and send your brief to logo@logo.ee or use the contact form. In the quote we will confirm production time, minimum quantity and price.
Sources
- Estonian Tax and Customs Board: gifts, donations and reception costs
- Estonian Tax and Customs Board: fringe benefits
- Estonian Tax and Customs Board: health and sport (fringe benefit guide)
- EUR-Lex: Council Directive (EU) 2016/1065 on the VAT treatment of vouchers
- American Economic Association: research on the value of gifts
- West Virginia University: study on digital gift cards